A film called ‘The Black Candle’
was shown in class which traced Kwanzaa’s roots. The film, although dated, was interesting and
prompted discussion afterwards which ensued about individuals’ knowledge of and
participation in this festival/celebration, individual experiences, the ways in
which individuals celebrate this event, where it originated, its meaning, etc. Opinions ranged regarding just why this
celebration was created and its significance – could it have been just another
excuse for African Americans to feast or was it the result of a Black
Nationalist response to the Watts riot of 1966 (Pleck, 2001). As it was created at a tumultuous time in the
United States, it is plausible of course, that Karenga’s political views may
indeed have affected his vision for Kwanzaa, as well as its evolvement over
time (Pleck, 2001).
Whether or not one believes in
and/or celebrates Kwanzaa, it definitely has different meanings for different
people and has both supporters and critics worldwide, whose views vary
significantly. When one examines
learning theories, Kwanzaa provides a good example of Wenger’s communities of
practice. Wenger (1998) in Communities of Practice, Learning, Meaning
and Identity examines and presents a social theory of learning among
groups. When one thinks of learning the
most conventional setting that often comes to mind is the process of learning
which takes place in the classroom between the student who receives information
and/or knowledge from the teacher and/or textbooks. Wenger however, describes the learning which
often takes place outside the classroom which is described as a process of
sharing information and experiences among group members in which group members
learn from each other.
There are many examples of
communities of practice which exist
whether it’s at home, at work, etc. however I will focus on Kwanzaa as an
example of a community of practice where participants share a common interest
and thus come together to celebrate what participants deem as culturally
relevant and meaningful. Members of this
particular group who share a common interest can be described as the
‘community’ and the ‘practice’ is the process of shared experiences and
knowledge among group members. It is
through this process of sharing and experiencing that group members continue to
learn.
There are both positives and
negatives associated with communities of practice. Positive aspects might include the benefit of
sharing experiences and knowledge, as well as providing a feeling of belonging
to a particular group. However on the
other hand if one does not belong and/or is deliberately excluded from a
particular community of practice they may feel isolated and/or rejected. Wenger’s theory of social learning forces one
to take a look at behaviours and other social aspects of everyday life which
affect how we learn.
Hello Helen,
ReplyDeleteAs you are aware, I am a storyteller and a storyteller tells stories. We are seldom brief. This can be entertaining in some situations but in others it is a curse. In my profession we strive to be as "pithy" as possible, short and precise. I can already hear your laughter. I can tell a story "pithy" but it is so hard for me!
When discussing a recent correspondence, Mark Twain said, if I had more time I would have been briefer.Brief insightful comments take time and understanding. They are reduced and refine to perfection, boiled down like a good stew and served hot.
You made this challenge look easy. You point out the obvious yet profound, "Whether or not one believes in and/or celebrates Kwanzaa, it definitely has different meanings for different people and has both supporters and critics worldwide, whose views vary significantly." Helen Desmond Morris
You make no apology.You show no bias. You sisinctly address the connection between Kwanzaa practice and Wenger's communities of practice theory. Your contribution is relevant and said with both pith and substance. I would have taken 2000 words, thank God you wrote it! Thanks Darlene